In many Asian societies, talking about money with people you know is not unlike talking about sex. We don’t really talk about it because it is awkward, but we’re also curious.
Unfortunately, this taboo about money and salaries has implications on transparency, fairness, and could perhaps be causing companies across the entire economy to inefficiently allocate resources.
At the same time, an open salary culture isn’t necessarily a silver bullet without repercussions. Let’s take a closer look at the issue to better understand the trade-offs we’re implicitly making, and what to expect if the practice of confidential salaries is overturned.
Asymmetric Information Leads To Poorer Outcomes For Employees
In Economics, price discovery is the process in which supply and demand meet – at exactly one point. In the event information is not forthcoming, then inefficiencies would occur – either buyers pay more than they need to, sellers price lower than they should, or a transaction not happening because of a mismatch in expectations.
The same can be applied to the job market. In the current culture of salary secrecy, employers have a disproportionate advantage, since they complete picture of how much they are paying all employees, and can get away with underpaying workers, with no one the wiser.
If employees ask for more than what the company is willing to pay, then the transaction (hire or pay raise) simply doesn’t happen.
The culture of salary opaqueness also leads to the constant nagging feeling of unfairness and jealousy, since it allows for the possibility of nepotism, favouritism, and overpaying of incompetent people.
It would also eliminate the fear that one is missing out on a higher salary simply because they were not a good negotiator, or lost out on higher pay just because they didn’t join the firm when the company was desperate to hire.
Finally, transparency keeps companies honest and closes any actual – or perceived – gender pay gap for women, seniors, or persons with disabilities. Any bias or patterns that can’t be justified by work responsibilities or capability would simply not be able to stand up to the light of day.
Open Salary Culture Exists In The Public Sector – And We’re Better Off For It
Opponents to an open salary culture say that overturning the status quo might lead to adverse consequences, such as disdain for management whom they don’t respect, or outrage at a perceived inferior peer earning more than them.
To put those concerns to rest, one simply needs to look at Singapore’s largest employer – the Public Service. There are 146,000 public officers working in 16 Ministries, more than 50 Statutory Boards, and 9 Organs of State.
The pay structure is transparent across the entire service, from entry-grade officers to those high in the Superscale ranks. Bonuses are also awarded according to a known formula based on performance evaluation and the publicly-announced bonus policy that year.
Thus, it is possible to calculate – with a great degree of accuracy – how much colleagues, boss, or subordinates are earning in the Public Service, and arguably public servants and Singapore society are better for it.
There are still plenty of ways to recognise and reward those who work hard and achieve better outcomes, whether that’s bonuses, promotional prospects, awards, or involvement in special projects and initiatives.
Ground-Up Platforms Like Glassdoor Chip Away At Closed Salary Cultures
Information is like Pandora’s Box: once it gets out, it is impossible to put it back in. And as much as companies want to keep their compensation policies secret, slowly, but surely, this information makes its way to the public domain – or at least informally within industry circles.
If companies pay poorly or exhibit a certain bias in their pay policy – they will be punished with a reputation they deserve. Likewise, companies that are known to overpay for incompetent talents with glossy resumes would deservedly attract the wrong candidates.
The success of platforms like Glassdoor and industry surveys also contribute to a slow, but sure democratisation of salary disclosures.
In fact, when advertising of job listings on MyCareersFuture and elsewhere, companies themselves would need to disclose the salary quantum (or at least a range) they are willing to pay, which also contributes to salary discovery.
These signs point to a gradual move towards an open salary culture in the future – perhaps sooner rather than later. Companies with nothing to fear wouldn’t be adversely impacted by this trend, while perhaps the promise of this being a reality would nudge companies in the right direction when it comes to paying people fairly.
DollarsAndSense.sg aims to provide interesting, bite-sized and relevant financial articles.
Learn together with like-minded Singaporeans at the Personal Finance Discussion SG Facebook Group by discussing a range of personal finance topics.
If you have not done so, subscribe to our free e-newsletter to receive exclusive content not available anywhere else.